17+ Fireplace Mantel Inserts That Still Steal the Show
Even when a fireplace is not in use, the mantel and insert area can be a decorative highlight of your living space. A creative insert not only complements the mantel but also becomes the true focal point of the room. From shelves and tilework to candles and greenery, these fireplace mantel insert ideas will steal the show all year long.
1. Stacked Logs Insert
Neatly arrange cut firewood in the insert for rustic charm, even if you aren’t burning a fire.
2. Candle-Filled Insert
Cluster pillar candles of varying heights to create soft, romantic lighting.
3. Seasonal Decorative Insert
Swap décor like pumpkins, ornaments, or spring florals throughout the year to keep the insert fresh.
4. Tile-Accented Insert
Line the insert with patterned tile for a bold, eye-catching finish.
5. Greenery and Plants
Fill the space with potted plants, ferns, or faux greenery for fresh, natural style.
6. Painted Pop of Color
Paint the inside of the insert in a contrasting color (like deep navy or cheerful yellow) to make it stand out.
7. Mirror Backing
Add a mirror to reflect light and make the fireplace feel larger and brighter.
8. Fairy Lights Insert
String warm fairy lights to create subtle sparkle and cozy ambiance.
9. Bookshelf Insert
Turn the empty space into a mini library with stacked books or styled shelves.
10. Art Piece Insert
Center a framed piece of artwork or a sculptural statement inside the fireplace opening.
11. Brick-Lined Insert
Highlight classic fireplace charm with exposed brickwork as a design feature.
12. Metallic Finish Insert
Add metallic tiles, copper sheets, or gold accents for a glamorous look.
13. Basket Accent Insert
Place a woven basket filled with pillows, throws, or linens for a homely, cozy style.
14. Whitewashed Insert
Brighten up the space with a painted or whitewashed fireplace interior.
15. Glass or Ceramic Vases Insert
Arrange interesting vases or decorative vessels in the opening for a modern twist.
16. Faux Fire Insert
Create the illusion of flames with LED logs or faux fire displays for year-round glow.
17. Minimalist Black Insert
Keep the look simple and chic with a matte black painted insert that frames the mantel beautifully.
Final Thoughts
The fireplace mantel often gets all the attention, but the insert area can be just as impactful. From rustic wood stacks to glossy tiles and creative decorative displays, your insert can highlight your fireplace and set the tone for the entire space. The right insert ensures your fireplace steals the show—even without a roaring fire.
